Email prospecting: how to get more responses?

Email prospecting: how to get more responses?

Email prospecting: how to get more responses?

Email is a prospecting channel for salespeople. However, the high level of competition on this channel necessitates thorough work on each message (in other words, each email) to stand out from the crowd.

Indeed, most prospecting emails go unanswered. To stand out from the crowd, you need to adopt best practices in email marketing. In particular, you'll benefit from focusing on the three key elements of personalization, contextualization, and automation for each email.

Article Summary
Email prospecting: how to get more responses?
Email prospecting: how to get more responses?

Need more leads ?
Try Magileads!

Personalize your sales prospecting emails

Email prospecting is a common practice used by salespeople to schedule appointments. Inexpensive, email marketing is affordable for most businesses . It is also perceived as less intrusive than telemarketing by decision-makers. Indeed, they can check an email at a time of their choosing without necessarily interrupting their current activity.

However, the success of email as a marketing channel has led to inbox saturation for customers. In B2B, a decision-maker receives up to 100 prospecting messages daily.

Therefore, if you want your messages to be opened, read, and generate engagement, you must optimize every element of your email campaign. Recipients quickly detect mass emails that offer no real added value. These will be deleted or marked as spam.

To achieve your goals, you need to create emails that stand out. And to do that, you should focus on personalizing each email.

 

Segment your contact lists

The email prospecting file you have created likely contains different types of target customers. 

Indeed, they can differ in their job title, type of company, or industry sector. Beyond socio-demographic data, behavioral data can also reveal divergent interests. But above all, they don't all have the same level of awareness regarding your offering. For some, the intention to buy is strong, while for others, it's not yet evident.

In your prospecting campaigns, you won't send the same message to a mature prospect as to a prospect who barely knows you. Similarly, you'll create distinct messages for recipients with different profiles.

To do this, you need to define relevant segmentation criteria based on your offering and objectives. Then, you will create messages tailored to each segment. A segment is defined as a homogeneous group of individuals with similar characteristics.

Segmentation allows us to:

  • Select the most qualified prospects for a sales contact
  • Personalize your messages based on the chosen segmentation criteria

Sending automated emails to segmented lists is useful when prospects are still relatively young, as part of a lead nurturing strategy. However, further along the buyer's journey, during a sales contact, personalization needs to be refined.

 

Conduct preliminary research on your target prospect

Segmentation allows you to group prospects with common characteristics. It is therefore a good marketing starting point for building a sales pitch that addresses shared problems. 

However, this alone is not enough to guarantee high performance for your marketing emails. Indeed, the competition in inboxes is so fierce that only the most engaging messages will deliver results.

To stand out from the crowd, you need to create emails perfectly aligned with your recipients' needs. That's why it's essential to conduct preliminary research before sending a prospecting email.

First, you can view their prospect record in your CRM tool to see their profile information and history. Then, you'll also find relevant information on LinkedIn in various places:

  • His recent activity
  • Recent news or events from his company

By doing this research, you'll have a better chance of finding an engaging hook for your message. You could, for example, build on one of their recent posts, a recent company success, or important industry news.

For example, if you are an international management consultant and discover on LinkedIn that your prospect's company will soon be opening new offices in England, you have an ideal angle of attack.

 

Tailor your message to the contact's position in the buyer's journey

Prospecting marketing emails work well when they provide value to the prospect. That's why personalization is essential. But personalizing a message doesn't just mean adding a "first name" field to an email template. It's far from enough.

More than personalization, we should really be talking about contextualization. An email is effective when the right message is sent to the right person at the right time. The performance level of an email campaign depends largely on the sender's ability to understand and use context.

To do this, it is necessary to:

  • Know your target audience (profile and history)
  • Do some preliminary research to find a relevant hook
  • Knowing your position in the buyer's journey

Indeed, you must adapt your messages, providing value at each stage of the sales cycle. Email marketing is built in sequences. Most contacts won't respond to the first message but only after several interactions. With each new message, you must focus on providing value and avoiding rejection. The initial contact email isn't about making a sale. It's about creating opportunities to engage the prospect and encourage them to continue the conversation.

Need more leads?
Try Magileads!

Prospecting: Write a high-performing email subject line

You can have an exceptional offer and write the best marketing emails in the world. All of that is useless if the recipients don't open your messages. 

During the initial contact, your recipient may not know you. In this case, the email subject line is the only thing that can convince them to open your message. The average open rate for B2B email marketing is between 20 and 25%. But this isn't inevitable. You can significantly improve these rates by adopting a few best practices.

Let's assume you've properly segmented your database and conducted preliminary research on your recipient. Now you know that in their inbox, your message will be competing with other marketing emails. In a fraction of a second, the prospect will decide whether your message goes straight to the trash or deserves their attention. What will make the difference?

The subject line has only one purpose: to entice the recipient to read your message. Don't try to sell anything or say too much. That would be counterproductive.

 

To optimize your email subject lines, you can adopt these 4 tips:

  • Keep it concise and to the point (7-8 words maximum)
  • Personalize your item with the contact's first/last name or their company name
  • Adopt a natural and honest tone (don't overact)
  • Do not include your company name in the subject line

Need more leads?
Try Magileads!

The body of the email: value and conciseness

How to create a marketing email that provides value?

The hook

The prospect has opened your message. Congratulations! But the battle is far from over. At the first sign of boredom, they could still decide to delete your email and end the business relationship you were hoping to initiate.

After the subject line, the opening line is your second opportunity to make a good first impression. That's why it absolutely must be contextualized based on your preliminary research.

A common mistake is to introduce yourself at the beginning of the message: "Hello, I'm Jean-Pierre Durand, sales manager for Dupont Mobilier, the leading office furniture company in the Franche-Comté region for businesses…". However, at this stage, your contact isn't yet interested in who you are.

By starting this way, you're very likely to get overlooked. Decision-makers already receive dozens of messages that begin this way. So you're not differentiating yourself. Worse, you're not adding any value.

Therefore, it's best to prioritize a prospect-centric approach, focusing on their specific challenges. This shows them they're not just another contact in a mass email campaign. You understand their situation and context. So, it might be worth reading your message to the end.

 

The introduction of your offer

Once you've set the scene with your opening line, the prospect understands that you're aware of their challenges. They see you as a valuable contact and are ready to continue the conversation.

Now is the time to introduce your offer. Here again, subtlety is key. It's not about presenting all the features or even all the advantages of your offer. It's about saying: " We've identified a problem that's holding you back. Well, we have the solution ."

You can show that you are an expert in your field, for example, by sharing content on the subject.

 

The call-to-action and email signature

The goal of a business email is often to schedule a meeting. In any case, you want a response. The best way to get one is to ask. The message structure is as follows:

  • You have a problem
  • We have the solution
  • Shall we talk about it?

This third step is the call to action. You want to encourage the prospect to take a step in your direction, to perform an action. For example, if it's about getting a sales appointment, your call to action could take this form: " Will you be available on Tuesday at 11 a.m. to chat for a few minutes about the new layout of your workspace?"

Finally, the email signature provides the recipient with the contact information needed to continue the conversation. But beyond this practical use, you can also use it to promote content or an event you're organizing.

 

Format: prioritize conciseness when prospecting

Decision-makers have little time to devote to prospecting emails. Therefore, now is not the time to launch into lengthy explanations. If you say too much, you'll jeopardize your chances of a future meeting. And, even worse, you're more likely to bore your contact.

Remember that the goal of your message isn't to sell, but to initiate a conversation that will ultimately lead to a sale. This distinction is important. To spark curiosity and desire, you shouldn't reveal everything, just the bare essentials.

Structure your initial contact emails in 4 to 5 sentences using this model: hook – introduction of the offer – call to action. Leave a line break between each section to make your message more readable and easier to break up. This also allows the reader to pause between each step.

Furthermore, prioritize a natural presentation in terms of design. Your email should resemble a classic, friendly message. By opting for a fancy template and using too many images, you're already overdoing it. The risk is that the prospect will see you coming a mile away with your sales pitch and won't want to engage further.

Need more leads?
Try Magileads!

How to create an effective prospecting email sequence?

Why is it necessary to send follow-up emails?

One of the secrets to the success of top-performing salespeople is perseverance. For many reasons, the first email often goes unanswered. 

This doesn't necessarily mean it was bad or irrelevant. Perhaps the recipient set it aside and forgot to look at it again. Perhaps it didn't arrive at the right time. Or perhaps you didn't emphasize the right points.

In any case, unless the other person has expressly refused your proposal, you can try again. You can even follow up with 7 or 8 attempts. 

 

How to organize your follow-ups?

Much like the encore at the end of a concert, you'll benefit from organizing your follow-up strategy. This involves preparing email sequences and automating them based on specific criteria.

For example, you wouldn't send the same follow-up message to a prospect who opened the message and clicked on a link as you would to a prospect who didn't even open it. Thanks to your tracking tools, you can see how the recipient interacted with your initial message. This allows you to tailor your first follow-up and send it within 24 to 48 hours.

The first follow-up email can be used to:

  • Present a second value proposition to the prospect
  • Ask him if he was able to see your first message

In any case, creating email sequences means you shouldn't reveal all your sales pitches in the first email. You need to be able to add value to each new message you send. 

Need more leads?
Try Magileads!

4 business email templates

2 examples of initial contact emails

The first message in the sequence, the initial contact email, is particularly important. Even if it doesn't necessarily generate an immediate commitment, the recipient will often read it and form an opinion about you.

This message can therefore strongly influence whether other messages in the sequence are opened and their outcome. It's crucial to carefully craft your opening line to entice the prospect to continue reading. In marketing emails, each sentence must be written to make your contact want to read the next.

In the opening line, you can, for example, use a recommendation from a mutual contact: 

Hello Antoine,

Jean-Pierre Durand recommended that I contact you. We are working together on the content strategy for Dupont Mobilier.

He told me about your difficulties in generating qualified traffic to your site. This is precisely one of the problems our offer addresses.

Will you be available next Tuesday at 11am to discuss this for a few minutes?

If you don't have a mutual contact, you can use company news as a starting point

Hello Antoine,

I have just read the article in the Courrier Franc-Comtois about Antoine & Co.'s international expansion project. 

However, I noticed that your website is exclusively in French. Do you plan to make it available in English? This is precisely one of the issues our offering addresses.

Will you be available on Wednesday at 3pm to discuss this for a few minutes?

2 examples of follow-up emails

For the first follow-up email, you can start with a reminder. The idea of ​​this first message is simply to reiterate the terms of the initial sales contact message.

 

RE: Content Strategy Antoine & Co

Hello Antoine

I wanted to make sure you received my email from last week. As a reminder, I proposed we discuss adapting the content of your website for English. 

Will you be available tomorrow at 10am to discuss this for a few minutes?

Or can I contact one of your colleagues on your behalf to discuss this issue?

THANKS.

Good day.

To provide even more value to your contact, you can include a link to relevant content related to their issue in your follow-up. For example: 

 

RE: Content Strategy Antoine & Co

Hello Antoine

I wanted to know if you had a chance to read my message from last week. As a reminder, I proposed that we discuss adapting the content of your website for English.

I recently published this article on the advantages of having a multilingual website.

Will you be available next Monday at 2pm to discuss this?

 

Why use Magileads for your email prospecting?

Prospecting by email requires perseverance. It's common for a salesperson to only manage to engage a prospect after the 6th or 7th message.

Obviously, performing these multiple follow-ups manually would be extremely tedious and time-consuming. That's why it's advisable to turn to a solution that allows you to create automated sequences.

With Magileads, you can easily create prospecting email workflows to send messages tailored to your contact and their level of engagement. For example, you can follow up with a prospect in just a few clicks based on an action they took after your previous message.

Thanks to its lead scoring feature, Magileads also allows you to accurately assess a prospect's buying intent. This enables you to decide whether to send a personalized offer or schedule a sales call if you determine the prospect is sufficiently ready to buy.

During the initial contact, your email tracking data is automatically integrated into the Magileads CRM. At the time of the call, you have a complete picture of how the prospect interacted with your messages, which ones they opened, whether they clicked on any links, or performed any other action.

This behavioral data allows the salesperson to adapt their pitch and boost performance.

Email prospecting: how to get more responses?

Expert references and credible studies

Recent studies:
A SalesHandy analysis (2023) reveals that personalized emails increase response rates by 32% compared to generic emails. The full study is available at saleshandy.com .
According to a Lemlist report (2024), using personalized videos in prospecting emails boosts responses by 41%. See the study at lemlist.com .

Renowned expert
Jill Konrath, author of “Selling to Big Companies,” emphasizes: “Relevance trumps quantity in modern prospecting.” Her full analysis is available at jillkonrath.com .
Steli Efti, CEO of Close.com, explains: “Systematic follow-up triples your chances of getting a response.” Find his method at close.com .

Direct testimonies

Marc L., B2B Sales Manager
: “By segmenting our database by sector and personalizing each email, our response rate increased from 3% to 11% in 3 months.”

Sophie T., Founder of a SaaS startup
: “Adding a short introductory video to my emails increased my appointments by 25%.”

Alexandre R., Independent Consultant
: “I tested sending on Tuesday at 10:30 am as registered mail and my responses increased by 40%.”

Élodie M., Marketing Manager
: “The simple question technique ('Need a solution for X?') has doubled our leads.”

Thomas P., Business Developer:
“By limiting my emails to a maximum of 100 words, I reduced my average response time from 5 to 2 days.”

Stories and anecdotes

The anecdote about the subject line in 3 words:
A company tested an ultra-short subject line (“Solution for X?”) against a traditional one. Result: +58% opens.

The case of creative follow-up:
A salesperson sent personalized memes after 3 unanswered emails. 35% of prospects eventually responded.

The story of the surprise video:
A startup included a 15-second video showcasing their product on a prospect's LinkedIn page. Response rate: 28%.

The perfect timing experiment:
By analyzing 10,000 emails, an agency discovered that 2 p.m. on Thursday was the ideal time slot for replies.

The minimalist signature test:
A company removed all but one link from its signature. Result: +22% clicks on the main CTA.

Strategic segmentation

Segmentation typeConcrete applicationKey profit
Sector (VSE/SME/ETI)Messages tailored to specific challengesIncreased relevance
Behavioral (interaction history)Targeted follow-up for non-respondersBest re-engagement rate
Technographic (tools used)Specific integration proposalPerceived value increased
Time-bound (time of sending)Sending during the prospect's peak activity periodsOptimized open rate
Psychographic (values)Alignment with stated prioritiesEmotional connection

Diagram:
[Process] Search → Customization → Sending → Tracking → Analysis

Questions/Answers

What is the average response rate for email prospecting?
In 2024, the average rate is between 1% and 5%, depending on the sector. The best campaigns reach 15-20% with hyper-personalization.

How many follow-ups should you send?
Woodpecker's data shows that 4 to 7 follow-ups spaced 3-4 days apart optimize responses without becoming tiresome.

Should you use templates?
Yes, but they should be at least 30% personalized. A study by Yesware shows that semi-personalized emails outperform generic ones by 65%.

What's the ideal length for a prospecting email?
Between 50 and 125 words, according to an analysis by Boomerang. Emails that are too long see their response rate drop by 40%.

How to improve your open rate?

  1. Topics of 3-5 words

  2. Use of the first name

  3. Simple question

  4. Avoid spammy words

  5. Optimal sending time

What tools are recommended?

  1. Lemlist for the sequences

  2. Hunter for research

  3. Mailchimp for analytics

  4. Loom for videos

  5. Crystal for the right tone

How to measure effectiveness?
5 key metrics:

  1. The opening rate

  2. Response rate

  3. Average response time

  4. Conversion rate

  5. ROI per campaign

 

Need more leads?
Try Magileads!

More articles on email prospecting

Business development

Business development

B2B Sales Prospecting: Finding Clients Effectively Article Summary What is sales prospecting? (sales, prospects…) Sales prospecting is an essential activity for the success and sustainability of a business. To identify business opportunities,

Read more "

Our latest blog posts

Nicolas, co-founder of Magileads

Got it, we'll send it to you
right away!


our free 2025 playbook on
multi-channel prospecting